.
Feedback

The Winds of Change

I know that many people in District 3 have felt for a long time that no listens or cares when they cry foul. But it appears that at last, the winds of change are starting to blow through here.

I know that many people in District 3 have felt for a long time that no one listens or cares when they cry foul. But it appears that at last, the winds of change are starting to blow through here. On Sunday, a new Atlanta Journal-Constitution article, outlined the complex corruption investigations in county government.

 I wish I could say this was shocking news. When I started my campaign, I painstakingly reviewed the school budget. One of the things I kept finding is just how difficult it is to question the status quo. For example, my team and I noticed with curiosity a line item "Banking Fees and services for central office and local schools (including fees for investment ad." It turns out this is where the the $150,000 is buried (and probably has been for 5 years) to pay for 2 economic development folks at the Chamber. When GCPS defended the positions by claiming without empirical data that Partnership Gwinnett brought $800 million to the area, providing $6 million in tax revenue to GCPS, curiosity turned to disbelief.

Disbelief turned to frustration when we saw that the board had plans to continue building new schools, despite almost stagnant anticipated growth, declining revenue and thousands and thousands of available seats in existing schools. How can we be in expansion mode when we don’t have enough teachers?

Earlier that same year, the AJC had released several articles about school board land deals. Presumably because of the stories, the school board did an internal investigation (at tax payer expense) that recommended more transparency and professionalism. As a taxpayer and a parent, I would have expected that at the outset and I would have insisted on it as a board member. Do you really have to pay internal investigators to learn that your staff should only buy properties that you, the board, approved?

Most “regular people” (like you and me) would have better sense than to base million dollar deals on executive summaries of appraisals. If appraisals on a single property vary by more than 30 percent, can you not guess that more research is needed? And, I am certain that most “regular people” would know better than to discuss sensitive financial information while a negotiation is in progress. 

It bears mentioning that GCPS could have allowed the county district attorney to investigate allegations of impropriety without needing additional funds. It’s what I would have elected to do. How much did this cost taxpayers? Stay tuned on Facebook this week to find out!

Since we are still building schools and buying new properties, I hope our board has learned from their mistakes. In the meantime, I am heartened to see that the district attorney and even the FBI are taking notice of area politics in general. Of course it brings none of us any joy to see tarnish on the sterling reputation of Gwinnett County. It affects our property values, our job growth potential and those things affect our schools and therefore, our children’s futures.  But the time has come to clean up the mess so that we can start fresh and restore our collective reputations.

Hayley Wright September 12, 2012 at 02:45 pm
Do I understand correctly that the board did not vote on the chamber positions? How could that happen without board approval?
Sabrina Smith September 12, 2012 at 05:26 pm
This is from a written statement given to me by GCPS in February:
"Superintendent J. Alvin Wilbanks approached the Gwinnett County Board of Education about the district appropriately joining the Partnership Gwinnett initiative. The Board agreed with the benefits outlined and the funding approach identified. The Board insisted that the funding be done on an annual basis and that the benefits of the district’s involvement be evaluated each year. " Despite that statement, subsequent open records requests revealed NO minutes from any board meeting, NO annual evaluations, and NO other documentation at all except for invoices from the chamber. When questioned about this, GCPS issued a statement that Wilbanks had the authority to make this expenditure without board approval. To view the original documents, go to www.GwinnettPetition.com.
Sabrina Smith September 12, 2012 at 05:28 pm
The Georgia Department of Education is currently having its auditors review the payments to the Gwinnett Chamber to determine if there was any impropriety.
PTC Concerns September 13, 2012 at 06:34 pm
Jen - I would hope that as a candidate for the District 3 school board seat you would have a better understanding of the number of students in the norcross cluster and the size of the schools. Where are these 1000's of seats? They aren't in district 3. Peachtree Elementary has almost 1700 students in a school designed for 1300. Stripling, Beaver Ridge and Norcross (elementary schools) are also over capacity. All of these schools are serving mostly disadvantaged students, many non english speaking, and do so on a shoe string budget. We don't just need to plan for more schools. We need more schools, teachers and administrators and we need them now. Or we need to bulldoze some apartments.
PTC Concerns September 13, 2012 at 06:41 pm
That said....Why buy and build anything ? You can throw a rock in any direction and hit vacant commercial office space in Gwinnett. If Cornerstone Christian and Ivey Prep operate successfully in office type buildings why can't a public school? I am sure the landlords would welcome a long term lease. There wouldn't be any land deals to investigate. No land and construction bonds to pay interest on.
Sabrina Smith September 13, 2012 at 06:42 pm
Perhaps if GCPS had not given the Gwinnett Chamber approximately $900,000, they could use that money in the schools operating on a shoestring budget. I wonder if the Gwinnett Chamber feels any guilt about taking money away from school children?
PTC Concerns September 13, 2012 at 06:47 pm
BTW - did any of you readers follow the link from Jen's article to her website and read the GC open records note at the bottom? It costs $43.54 per hour to fulfill an open records request. That amount is based upon the wage of the lowest skilled full time employee trained to fulfill the request. Really? It takes a $90,000 a year employee to fulfill records requests? Really Gwinnett?
Annette Rogers September 13, 2012 at 10:34 pm
PTC Concerns,
I have closely followed GCPS capacity and enrollment, especially for the past 3 years. Norcross and Duluth Clusters are divided across Districts. Beaver Ridge, Norcross, and Stripling are in District 5 as is Chesney Elementary in the Duluth Cluster. I apologize that I am unable to accurately compare current capacity with enrollment at this time. GCPS, according to Jorge Gomez on behalf of "my school board", is unable (unwilling?) to provide capacity figures for this year or for last year. Therefore, Jen has been using capacity projections from the GCPS planning department that I suspect average at least 10% below actual current capacity because of the increased class sizes. I agree, as both you and Jen have stated, that the classes are too large. I also agree with you that the largest, especially Elementary schools, seem to have lowest socio-economics and most diverse populations. Personally, I have wondered if this is intentional "segregation" by our school board to "create" Title I schools to receive funding, e.g., Simpson vs Peachtree and Mason vs Chesney. I'd be glad to share my research and thoughts with you. I think we can "connect" as Patch neighbors and share messages/contact information.
Lisa Poissant Edwards September 16, 2012 at 06:42 pm
PTC Concerns - you are so right! This is just one way that they keep citizens & taxpayers from getting information! Besides the cost there are also stall tactics of 'we don't have that' 'you didn't request that correctly' etc. that just makes you wonder how much MORE they are hiding from us! We are taxpayers paying their salaries - we have a right to an open & transparent GCPS!
J September 16, 2012 at 06:43 pm
PTC Concerns - your point is yet ANOTHER way information is barred from us - they will tell a taxpayer that the 'open records' request will take 'x' amount of hours which ='s too high a cost - which kills the request!! Or even better is the answer 'that's not available - we don't have it' - as taxpayers we should not have to fight to get information from our own School Board - ! No wonder we don't know what's going on with our taxpayer money and the Gwinnett Chamber of Commerce!

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Duluth Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something